There are tons of amazing TV shows that set the world on fire with their stories but, for some reason or another weren't continued. It's tragic enough when a long-running series gets curtained, but it's even more heartbreaking when a stellar show begins to hit its stride, and then gets abruptly canceled. We turned to Reddit to find out which canceled shows people miss the most. Whether you're mourning a beloved show, or want an introduction to some television gold, here are 10 series that came and left far too quickly!

1. Mindhunter

Photo Credit: Netflix.

One user said, “Probably anything canceled by Netflix.”

Another user replied, “Mindhunter has entered the chat.”

A third added, “Mindhunter is the first series I actually got super bummed out about being canceled. The story, actors, and music. Shame.”

One Redditor commented, “Soundtrack was elite. Almost got lost in the shuffle of everything else is so well done.” 

Another user shared, “Inside Job made it two seasons before getting axed on a cliffhanger. I still want to know what happens.”

One commenter replied, “This is how I found out Inside Job got canceled… sigh.”

2. Rome

Photo Credit: HBO.

One user exclaimed, “ROME!!!!”

One commenter added, “Yes. Rome! It was Game of Thrones before Game of Thrones.”

One user replied, “Rome walked so GoT could run….into a post.”

“Yeah, the later seasons weren't as good, but I don't know how much better they could be considering everything that happened behind the scenes… Though I guess the real weakness was injecting Caesar and that one guy's the stupid horrible son. Ugh…yeah…now I'm remembering everything…geez… you're right…I was only thinking about the first season and the prequel,” one user responded. 

3. 2003 Teen Titans

Photo Credit: Warner Bros Animation.

One user posted, “This may seem a bit childish, but Teen Titans—the original one from 2003…

Another replied, “It’s a bummer because every character got one season where they were the focus of the ongoing plot. Season 1 was Robin, season 2 was Terra, season 3 was Cyborg, season 4 was Raven, and season 5 was Beast Boy. It was set up perfectly to have a 6th season focused on Starfire, and we never got it.” 

One commenter added, “Rewatched the whole series reasonably recently. It really was such a unique show for the time. I remember seeing reruns on Boomerang after the series had finished airing on CN. Unfortunately, they no longer air anything from the original series or movie. Season 5 absolutely ended in a way that demanded something more, and the movie did not scratch that itch.”

4. Reaper

Photo Credit: ABC Studios.

“Reaper—Absolutely loved that [show], oh and Firefly, but everyone says that,” one Redditor posted.

Another user added, “I hate that they don't cast Tyler Labine in more comedy stuff. Reaper was a fantastic showcase of his hilarity, and one of my all-time favorite movies is Tucker and Dale vs. Evil.”

One user commented, “I can't believe Reaper was so far down the list.” 

Another added, “From what I remember, it was canceled because they wanted The Vampire Diaries in that time slot. Guess they made a good move, considering the success of TVD. But I still hate them for canceling it.” 

One user added, “The network canceled it, they tried to syndicate to SciFi, but the cast would have to take pay cuts, so they weren't on board, and then the showrunners were going to produce a comic book to at least wrap the cliffhanger they left us on, but… nothing. They did at least do an interview where they revealed the secrets behind Sam and the devil's deal, his parentage, etc., if you're interested. (Warning: spoilers for a show canceled 14 years ago).”

5. Jericho

Photo Credit: CBS.

One user posted, “Jericho.”

Another added, “Every time I see this thread, I come just to upvote or add Jericho. Nuts to CBS.”

One user also commented, “Same. I keep scrolling until I see Jericho, and then I upvote.” 

“Let's be honest. This would be one of the best ‘remakes' of our time. Jericho and not just season one and a half. But seasons 3, 4, 5, and 6. Let's see how the country is rebuilt. I would watch every last second of this. I also really like that long before preppers and all this other [stuff]. They were doing things that were way ahead of their time. Granted, they were probably public knowledge to somebody, but they weren't mainstream. And I thought that was really cool that they were touching on a lot of topics. I think this show was ahead of its time, and it was canceled during a writer's strike, and that [was terrible],” one user responded. 

Another user concluded, “I think HBO or Paramount would do a good job on a Jericho reboot. However, if it ever does happen, I hope they use the original cast.”

6. Venture Bros

Photo Credit: Cartoon Network.

One user posted, “Venture Bros.”

One of the users then shared, “Venture Bros was easily a solid decade ahead of its time.The Boys, Invincible, Harley Quinn, Doom Patrol, Peacemaker. All these shows deal with deconstructing the superhero mythos, and the Venture Brothers did this in 2004. At least we're getting a movie.”

“Venture Bros started as a pitch-perfect parody of old Hanna-Barbera cartoons and went on to skewer every element of pop culture they could get their hands on while maintaining well-written, context-driven comedy. It was never cheap. It was well-acted and scripted. It grew and evolved and allowed its characters to step outside the narrow channels they were born in, developing them from single characteristic, classic archetypes into something more complex. I [really] love the Venture Bros. Dead excited for the film, but I'd equally take another few seasons,” one user replied.

Another user concluded, “Honestly, the fact that most (all?) VB characters have some sort of arc is part of what makes the show great. Most shows (especially adult cartoons) have these flat, static characters. Venture bros are nothing like that.”

7. I Am Not Okay With This

Photo Credit: Netflix.

One user shared, “I Am Not Okay With This.”

Another responded, “It had so much potential, not to mention they left so much unanswered at the end of the season purposely so they could make a second one.”

One Redditor commented, “Netflix does not [care at all] about finishing a story. It is not worth investing any time in any of their content, even the stuff that looks good.” 

One user replied, “This cancellation made me give up on Netflix. I just can't get excited by anything on their platform at this point because I know whatever I get interested in, no matter how good it is, will get dropped without a conclusion. I WON'T LET THEM HURT ME AGAIN!” 

8. Pushing Daisies

Photo Credit: CBS.

One Redditor posted, “Pushing Daisies.”

One user replied, “Definitely this one. I loved the series and wanted to see where it was going.”

Another user seconded, “This and Dead Like Me. Both sensational shows.”

Another commenter responded, “I've just come to accept that anything Bryan Fuller makes, I'm going to love and then be heartbroken when it's canceled too soon.” 

One user commented, “Or when he's ousted from it. American Gods took an extreme nosedive when he left.”

One user also shared, “I don't really fault Fuller for Discovery. After all, CBS dropped him early in development, and they only used some of his outlines. As a result, the final product is different from what he was originally going for. As an example, he wanted to do an anthology series that explored many different eras of Star Trek.” 

One user concluded, “Yeah, I thought he was there for the whole production of season one, but reading the Wiki page, it looks like there was a lot of turmoil early on.”

9. Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency

Photo Credit: Netflix.

One of the Reddit users shared, “Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency. Edit: so many people didn't like the 2nd season, which is entirely fair. It's hard to live up to the expectations of such a solid first season. The reason I personally would like a 3rd season is that the cliffhanger is so damn tasty. Also, I want more Rowdy 3 (6?), Alan Tudyk, and Tyler Labine.

“I recognize that it deviates completely from the source material, and I understand why a lot of people are upset by that. There are a lot of examples where I hated the adaptation (looking at you, World War Z), but I personally believe this is a perfect example of how you take inspiration and run with it.

“A dark, gritty version where Dirk was the fat slob the books described him as might also be fantastic, and I'd probably watch… it. However, I think this adaptation perfectly captures the whimsical nonsense of Douglas Adam's writing, and I'm ok with it. It's just a shame that the show was attached to such a scumbag. Otherwise, we might have seen that 3rd season that gave us all the answers they teased.”

One user commented, “That show is still my absolute favorite. With absolute [great lines] like, ‘The Rowdy Three!', ‘But there are 4 of them!', ‘I'm WILDLY aware.'

“They captured Douglas Adams' whimsical nonsense so perfectly in that show. I feel like the second series went completely off the rails, but I still loved it.” 

“This was so gloriously, bizarrely brilliant. It was completely different from the (excellent) books, but it took on some of the core ideas and added a bunch of its own, then ran simultaneously with them in multiple directions. It was a joy to watch and made me feel an almost childlike wonder. It surprised and delighted me; a modern-day fairy-tale for grown-ups. Gutted it was canceled,” one user replied. 

Another user added, “It was a book adaptation done right. Borrowed concepts from the book, but instead of trying to squeeze the book's story onto the screen (which would have been a… trainwreck), they went their own way and made something unique.”

10. Better Off Ted

Photo Credit: 20th Century Fox Television.

One Redditor posted, “Better Off Ted. The show was a brilliant satire of corporate business that was far too funny. The amazing cast was incredibly quotable and ended far too soon. Punisher should have had a season 2 with more gang/mafia shenanigans. Altered Carbon should have been able to wrap up its story. Rubicon. It didn't have to be a continuation, but I would love to see more like it. Edit: I have corrected it. Punisher had a season 2—my mistake.

Another added, “The episode where they installed motion detectors for everything that didn't see black people, so they had to assign every black person a white person to open doors, but then because of diversity rules, they had to hire more black people was phenomenal.

Ted: ‘That's more than weird, Veronica. That's basically, well… racist.'

Veronica: ‘The company's position is that it's actually the opposite of racist because it's not targeting black people. It's just ignoring them. So they insist the worst people can call it is indifferent.'

Ted: ‘Well, they know it has to be fixed, right? Please… at least say they know that.'

Veronica: ‘Of course they do, and they're working on it. In the meantime, they'd like everyone to celebrate the fact that it sees Hispanics, Asians, Pacific Islanders, and Jews.'”

One user concluded, “Definitely. Whenever people ask me about good, fun TV, they usually know the standards like Office and 30 Rock, so I point them to Better off Ted and outline this specific episode. And each time, they are eager to check it out. It's such an unusual, new trope that hits all the right points.”

Original Reddit thread

More From Finance Quick Fix

Top 10 Most Excruciatingly Boring Movies Ever Produced

Image Credit: Paramount Pictures.

Have you ever gone to the theaters or purchased a rental, only to be entirely disappointed by how dull it was? You're not alone.

Top 10 Most Excruciatingly Boring Movies Ever Produced

10 Celebrities Had Their Big Break Then Dropped off the Face of the Earth

Nelly Furtado
Photo Credit: Shutterstock.

Some celebrities definitely seem to enjoy the limelight and keep working to stay in the public eye. While others quickly move out of the spotlight.

10 Celebrities Had Their Big Break Then Dropped off the Face of the Earth

15 Terrible Movies That Are Amazingly Enjoyable

Photo Credit: Warner Bros.

Here are 15 movies that are objectively terrible, but that people still love watching over and over again.

15 Terrible Movies That Are Amazingly Enjoyable

10 Absolute Worst Actors and Directors to Work With

Image Credit: Shutterstock – Denis Makarenko.

While some actors and directors have earned a reputation for being easy to work with and respectful of their colleagues, others have earned a reputation for being difficult and unprofessional.

10 Absolute Worst Actors and Directors to Work With


About the Author

+ posts